Alpha software of any sort tends to be pretty buggy. It’s basically the developers saying that they can make this work but need a bit more time and “watch this space”. Ubuntu 8.10 “Intrepid Ibex” Alpha 6 is no exception to the buggy rule. There are a number of things that don’t quite work. Saying that, it is not so bad as you might imagine, as I am writing this article quite happily from 8.10 “Intrepid Ibex”.
Alpha 6 is the last of the Alpha releases. The Beta release is due on the 2nd of October, and the Release Candidates will appear around the 23rd of October with the final release on the 30th of October.
I have had a look at the bug reports and the forums for Intrepid Ibex and things are being actively worked on. In the 24 hours since I installed, there have been a number of updates. I will be interested in logging onto this install and updating and seeing how things begin to work over the next few weeks.
It is interesting that the Free and Open Source Community is so open about the fact that things don’t quite work and how hard they are working to get them right.
So, after using it for a day or so, what doesn’t work?
The most obvious one is the wireless card that I have in this laptop. The Hardware Drivers sub-system comes up with the fact that the Broadcom 4318 card has been found and that there’s a driver available, however, the installation routine just doesn’t do anything. Dropping into the terminal and running the following command: sudo /usr/share/b43-fwcutter/install_bcm43xx_firmware.sh fixes it (just make sure you have a wired Internet connection).
I can then select my wireless network and it automatically selects the right encryption scheme. When I put in the WPA password it all connects correctly and I can browse my Local Area Network and the Internet (more on this on page 3).
However, I run into a problem when I restart. The system seems to forget the WPA password and I have to type it in again. Once this is done, it connects fine, so this is more of an annoyance than anything else. It has been reported as a bug and it is being worked on.
I want to listen to some music that I have on one of the shares, so I tell the music player, Rhythmbox, to go look there for the music. However, it doesn’t see any of the music files on the share. This is a Rhythmbox application issue and has been logged. I get around it by mounting the share in a different way (I want to write an article about how to do that soon) and I can successfully listen to my music.
I am sure there are more issues to be discovered, but that’s as far as I have tested so far.
My first impressions are that it’s all about the speed, the pretty and small improvements that make it more usable.
One of the generally accepted rules of computing seems to be that if you retain the same hardware and upgrade the operating system, then you can expect it to run slower. For example, Windows XP runs pretty well on my laptop, but Vista would be barely useable.
This seems to have been accepted as a fact of computing. But noone seems to have told the Free and Open Source Software (FOSS) community. They clearly don’t subscribe to this idea!
Ubuntu 8.10 “Intrepid Ibex” Alpha 6 absolutely flies on my laptop. It boots faster and generally feels more responsive than the 8.04 version, which again felt faster than 7.10 and 7.04.
At the same time, I have a lot more applets loading on startup (and software installed generally) in 8.04, so I will be interested to see what happens when I enable them in 8.10. I suspect that things will just be faster in 8.10 anyway as the quality of FOSS just keeps increasing.
The biggest difference is in the wireless speed. In Ubuntu 7.04 and 7.10, my Broadcom 4318 WLAN card used the bcm43xx driver, which had a maximum speed of 24Mbps (3MB/sec), although being wireless it was usually quite a lot slower. This was replaced by the b43 driver in 8.04, which usually connected somewhere between 11 Mbps and 36 Mbps (although due to a bug in Network-Manager which remains unfixed, it only ever showed that it was connected at 1Mbps). I was able to get about 1.2-1.5MB/sec when downloading off my ISP’s local file mirror.
However, in 8.10 I can get 2.3MB/sec, sustained, over wireless! I am quite close to the exchange and on ADLS2+ (theoretical maximum speed of 24Mbps), so I am pretty much maxing out that connection. Interestingly, this is faster than the speeds that the Vista SP1 machines in the house can achieve (about 1.5MBps for the same file).
Having a fast connection speed - Network-Manager tells me 54 Mbps at the moment - and good throughput on wireless is a very welcome change.
One thing to keep in mind is that (as far as I am aware) Broadcom themselves have not helped with this driver, it is the open source developer community that have improved it to this point.
The second good thing that I have noticed is that it is gorgeous to look at. Compiz (the 3D desktop) is enabled by default, so I get all the nice 3D effects. This is pretty incredible as I have an onboard video card which shares 128MB of the system RAM. Vista’s Aero would just laugh at this video card and tell it to grow up!
It also seems to be a lot easier on the eyes. If the Ubuntu team has selected new default fonts then I salute them.
Applications such as Firefox and Gedit (the default text editor, a bit like Notepad in Windows, but much more powerful) just look nicer. Enabling Subpixel Smoothing makes it even better (go to System, Preferences, Appearance. Under Fonts at the top, click on Subpixel Smoothing. Makes things look nice on an LCD screen).
It might not seem like much, but now I only have to have one file manager window open, and can open tabs and copy and paste files between the tabs. This is quite simply a time and screen real-estate saver saver. I wonder how long it will take Microsoft to incorporate a tabbed file manager?
Secondly, is the icons for safely ejecting removable media, such as CD/DVD drives and USB keys. This is a bit like Microsoft’s “Safely Remove Hardware” system, just straight from the file manager itself. I find this very useful as I use USB keys a lot to carry files with me.
All in all, this is shaping up to be an interesting addition to the Ubuntu line up.
As I type this, I have been notified that there are another 30.6MB of updates! Being Alpha software, it is under heavy development. I will be watching with interest to see how the developers and the community respond to the bugs that have been raised so far.
source